Quilting and Copyrights

by Charlotte Colmon

I've had a number of questions from readers about selling the quilts they make and copyright issues. These questions generally fall into two categories:

  • Can I sell a quilt I make from fabric that has licensed images (i.e. Disney, NASCAR, etc.)?
  • Can I sell a quilt I make from a pattern I purchase that is copyrighted?


These questions bring up some of the most common – and most confusing – issues involving copyright and quilting. There are all sorts of postings and articles on the Internet that talk about these questions, but I have yet to find a definitive answer. So, I turned to Google Answers to see if I could get some help.

I'm posting the answers I received, with my comments in italics. Since I'm not a lawyer, and I am NOT giving any legal advice, the best thing to do in this case is to discuss the situation with a lawyer. Again, I am not giving legal advice – this article contains opinions not expressed by Chuck Smith, QuiltingBusiness.com, or Gruntled Enterprises. So, enough of covering my backside…. on to the answers.

Here is the “gist”of the answers I received from Google (I am paraphrasing in my own words). To see the complete answers, please go to:

answers.google.com/answers/threadview?id=398157

Question: Can you sell quilts made from fabric that you purchase when most fabric designs are copyrighted?

Answer: The first question is the hardest among the two and there are different interpretations among the side of the fabric makers and crafters (like the quilters) as regards to this issue. Just like in any legal matter, nothing is absolute and not everything is black and white since there will always be exceptions in different cases.

This first link goes to an article by eBay Power Sellers Michael Meadors and Karen Dudnikov. They have successfully defended themselves against a number of different lawsuits brought by companies that have licensed their assets for use on fabrics. Mr. Meadors and Ms. Dudnikov have sold items made with licensed fabrics on eBay, and when push came to shove, the licensors have backed off.

What this means is that there is precedent for creating a quilt from fabric with licensed images or designs on them, and offereing them for sale. This seems to come under the “First Sale Doctrine” which is part of the current United States Copyright Law. Basically, the First Sale Doctrine states that when a manufacturer of a copyrighted item releases that item into the stream of commerce, the original owner of the copyright loses control of what happens to that particular item.

To read the complete article, please go to:

“Using Copyrighted Fabrics” By: Michael M. & Karen D., eBay's Tabberone

auction-resources.com/newsletter/news03222004.html

One of the arguments that big companies use to scare quilters and crafters is to refer to these hand-crafted items as unauthorized or unlicensed products. But, this argument is part of trademark law, not copyright law. But, since they are large companies, many quilters are too scared to go up against the big companies and don't use the fabric.

There is a federal court case that directly addresses the use of copyrighted fabric. The case, from 1997, involved Precious Moments vs. a company called La Infantil. “The only federal court case directly addressing the use of copyrighted fabric is Precious Moments v. La Infantil, 1997, 1st District. Precious Moments lost in its attempt to stop La Infantil from making bedding from licensed fabrics. We have been in federal court with M&M/Mars, Disney, Major League Baseball, United Media (Peanuts) over the use of licensed fabrics. Every one of them objected to the making and sale of fabric items. Everyone one of them wanted to settle after being sued.”

Here is a copy of the sole federal court case of copyrighted fabric by Moments v. La Infantil. Basically, in this decision, the court denied the copyright claim by Precious Moments, but did make La Infantil change the tags on their products to clearly show that Precious Moments was the owner of the copyrighted image (but La Infantil was allowed to continue to sell the products with the modification to the tags). The official document is here:

“PRECIOUS MOMENTS, INC., Plaintiff, v. LA INFANTIL, INC., et al., Defendants.
Civil No. 97-1635 (PG). July 29, 1997.”

www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/PreciousMoments/PreciousMoments.html

So in a sense, the crafter did not totally won since the latter was still ordered to modify the tags included with the products to properly cite that the plaintiff was the owner of the copyright for the fabric.

My take on this issue: You can sell quilts made from licensed fabric, and it fits into the First Sale Doctrine under copyright law. You can probably expect some grief from some of the bigger companies, but use the resources at www.TabberOne.com and you should be OK. Again, this is NOT a legal opinion, nor am I giving legal advice.

Question: Can you sell a quilt made from a copyrighted pattern? And if so, what are the restrictions and rules that would apply?

The case here seems to be a little more cut and dried. The quick answer is “No, you may not sell quilts made from a copyrighted pattern.” Here are a couple of resources that go into a great deal of detail about some of the issues:

“Copyright Facts for Crafters & Quilters” by Sylvia Landman

www.sylvias-studio.com/copyright.htm

Copyright & Quilters: a FAQ & Links”

quilting.about.com/library/weekly/aa000430.htm

The reason is that in the case of a qult pattern, the pattern itself is unavoidably copied and reproduced in the finished product – when you look at the finished quilt, you see a copy of the pattern you created the quilt from. In addition, most quilt pattern copyright holders will put in restrictions on use, so as “for personal use only” or other limiters. This is perfectly legal, and means you cannot sell the finished quilt.

But, there may be a way to sell a quilt from a copyrighted pattern. Basically, you need to ask the owner of the copyright if you can sell the quilt. You may have to come up with some kind of profit-sharing plan, but it never hurts to ask.

My take on this issue: It's better not to try to sell a quilt made from a copyrighted pattern unless you have permission from the copyright holder. Instead, use public domain patterns or come up with your own patterns. I know this makes things more difficult, but in the end, a lot safer.

I know this article may not be the most helpful I've posted, but at least you'll be exposed to a few new information resources to continue your hunt. Again, I'm not trying to give legal advice, and I'm not an attorney. Please consult a licensed attorney if you do have any questions about quilting and copyright.

If you have any questions about your quilting business – whether just starting out or looking for a boost with some solid marketing or business advice – feel free to send me an email at chuck@quiltingbusiness.com.

Chuck Smith is the owner of QuiltingBusiness.com, the web's only site dedicated to helping you make money with your quilting. Visit QuiltingBusiness.com today to sign up for the FREE email mini-course: “7 Unique Ways to Make Money with Your Quilting.”


PLEASE NOTE: This article and product review archive is here for your benefit. If you would like to use any of the articles or product reviews on your own web site or in your own email newsletter, you must include the resource box at the end of the article and also contact QuiltingBusiness.com to request permission.

{ 6 comments… read them below or add one }

Juanita Creekmore September 21, 2009 at 3:30 pm

I got it, thank you for i did’nt know that.

Thank You.
Juanita Creekmore
919-223-5777

Cindy Richard December 26, 2009 at 12:01 pm

I have asked permission to show my work that was based on a copyrighted pattern in a few cases. Because I had purchased the pattern, I was asked to give credit for the design in my post, which I did. It was correct to ask for permission and the response was reasonable. We all benefit.
CindyRQuilts

Elena April 24, 2010 at 11:41 am

Yeah, you propably right about this second matter (selling quilts made from copyrighted pattern). But I would like to bring your attention to the exact mening of the phrase, which is standing at the beginning of the most quilting magazines (I too buy some ower internet):

The unauthorised reproduction or distribution of this copyright work is illegal.

It means to me (though I could have poor knowledge of English) that protected is the work in the magazine (i.e. the description how to make a quilt plus pictures) but not the quilt I made using this instructions and pics. Otherwise it would be prohibited to make quilt – you were only able to read articles and look at the illustrations, isn’t it?
What do you think about it?

Melissa Cordstone May 14, 2010 at 1:18 pm

these are some really interesting considerations. it makes it hard to be a crafter if you have to always be worried about copyright, when you are just trying to make something nice like a quilt.

Laurie in Maine November 20, 2010 at 1:07 am

Next thing you know we’ll need permission to hang a quilt on the clothesline on laundry day…someone might see it!

sandy October 7, 2014 at 11:59 am

I still don’t think there is a black and white answer if you do tag a product hand crafted can you sell it legallyto use lienced fabric ? If how should it be tagged

Leave a Comment

{ 1 trackback }

Previous post:

Next post: